Facebook opens investigation into private groups sell and soliciting human remains


Facebook is investigating new charges that people are using private groups to sell and solicit human remains, including skulls, fetal remains, and even a mummified six-year-old child dated to the 1700s.

While Facebook has a policy that explicitly bans the ‘buying or selling of human body parts or fluids,’ some users appear to have gotten around the prohibition by taking advantage of the site’s private groups feature. 

Many of the remains listed are claimed to have come from archeological or historical sites around the world, with one seller saying they looted a human skill from catacombs in Sousse, Tunisia, which was offered for $550.

Facebook users have formed private groups to sell and solicit human remains, including skulls, fetal remains, and a mummified six-year-old child dating to the 1700s

The private groups were discovered by LiveScience, which spent 10 months investigating the listings and cataloging the range of items offered for sale or requested by other users.

Legal experts warn that these practices are also criminal under both US and international law, as well as a threat to governmental and academic efforts to preserve historical artifacts at archeological sites around the world.

‘It is doubtful that any person, even those donating their remains for science, ever wanted to be or expected to be a personal curio for an individual,’ Ryan Seidemann and Christine Halling from the Office of Louisiana’s Attorney General in the Lands & Natural Resources Section Civil Division, jointly told LiveScience in an email.

‘Even more clear are the human remains that derive from tombs or burials. Those people intended for their remains to stay in their burial space.’ 

‘Violation of this intent for the purposes of seeking to privately own or possess the remains is both a legal and an ethical violation.’ 

The investigation documented a wide range of different listings, including one user who was attempting to sell a mummified six-year-old child for around $12,247 (11,000 Euros), claiming they dated back to the 1700s.

Facebook says it has opened an investigation into the groups, which violate the company's terms of service, which bans the 'buying or selling of human body parts or fluids'

Facebook says it has opened an investigation into the groups, which violate the company’s terms of service, which bans the ‘buying or selling of human body parts or fluids’

One seller listed a human skull for $1,300, claiming it had come from a ‘young teen female,’ but offered no other information on its origin.

A separate listing described an elongated skull claimed to have come from Peru, on sale for $10,500.

It appeared potentially similar to elongated skulls discovered in Peru in 2014, believed to have come from a 2,000 year-old group of hunter gatherers that practiced artificial cranial deformation.

Though many listings don't specify the origin source for their listed items, some point to important archeological sites, including a listing for a skull claiming to be from catacombs in Sousse, Tunisia

Though many listings don’t specify the origin source for their listed items, some point to important archeological sites, including a listing for a skull claiming to be from catacombs in Sousse, Tunisia

Several users listed fetal remains preserved in jars, claiming they were 'retired medical specimens'

Several users listed fetal remains preserved in jars, claiming they were ‘retired medical specimens’

The process typically involved tying cloths or wooden bracing devices around a young child’s head to force it to grow into an elongated shape.

Still another user listed fetal remains preserved in a jar for $2,350, which they claimed was a ‘retired medical specimen.’

Another seller listed an ‘almost full-term’ fetus for $6,495, claiming that its mother had ‘wanted this specimen to live on via preservation and to stimulate curiosity and further education about the human body.’

In recent years, similarly illicit markets for human organs and remains have quietly emerged on eBay and Instagram, prompting new fears that social media and online marketplaces might help popularize what was once an exceedingly rare practice.

Facebook hasn’t made any official announcements about its investigation into the private user groups, but three have already been shut down for undisclosed reasons.