Joanna Cherry sacked from SNP frontbench after trans rights row

Joanna Cherry, a prominent SNP MP, has been sacked from the party’s frontbench in Westminster.

Ms Cherry, widely tipped as a future SNP leadership challenger to Nicola Sturgeon and an ally of previous leader Alex Salmond, said she had been removed from her role despite ‘hard work, results & a strong reputation’.

The QC, who has been involved in an internal party row over gender recognition and trans rights, delivered a parting shot as she said the SNP needs to ‘radically rethink our strategy’.  

The move was announced by Ian Blackford, the SNP’s Westminster leader, as part of a wider reshuffle as he said ‘team working and cooperation are key to ensure results and this reshuffle will give us a strong team to take us forward’. 

The decision to sack Ms Cherry prompted a furious backlash from supporters as fellow SNP MP Kenny MacAskill tweeted: ‘I know how highly rated Joanna Cherry is in UK justice circles as well the party grassroots in Scotland. 

‘She remains head and shoulders above most others and I for one stand by her. This is the leadership’s call but many of us find this inexplicable and harmful to our cause.’

An official reason for removing Ms Cherry from the frontbench was not given by the SNP amid speculation that it could have been because of the trans rights row or because she is viewed as a leadership threat to Ms Sturgeon. 

An SNP Parliamentarian told The National newspaper they believed Mr Blackford had sacked Ms Cherry with Ms Sturgeon’s approval. 

‘It’s been well known that Jo and Nicola have not been getting on well for a long time,’ they said. ‘Ian Blackford was the willing stooge to wield the knife. There is no way this would have happened without Nicola Sturgeon. Not a chance.’

Meanwhile, an SNP source claimed to the New Statesman that the dismissal was for ‘continued gross disloyalty’. 

Joanna Cherry said this afternoon she had been sacked from the SNP’s Westminster frontbench

Ms Cherry has been a vocal critic of Nicola Sturgeon and is widely tipped as a future SNP leadership challenger

Ms Cherry has been a vocal critic of Nicola Sturgeon and is widely tipped as a future SNP leadership challenger 

Ms Cherry has faced criticism from some within the SNP for her stance on transgender issues. 

There is an ongoing row in the party on the issue of gender recognition, with some strongly opposed to moves by the Scottish Government to make it easier for people to legally change their gender identity.

The issue arose after the Scottish Government put forward plans to legislate on gender recognition reform, which would have eased the process of legally changing gender identity.

The plans, which were scrapped last year after the coronavirus pandemic hit, would have meant trans people could receive a Gender Recognition Certificate through self-declaration after six months, rather than requiring medical evidence and a two-year period of living as that gender under the current rules.

Ms Cherry had been a high-profile critic of the planned reform. She has previously said she is ‘not remotely transphobic’ and supports the rights of trans people. 

Speaking in March 2020 she said politicians must stand up to ‘bullies in the gender lobby who want to shut down the right to free speech’. 

Ms Sturgeon last week vowed to tackle transphobia within the SNP if it exists, insisting she takes on ‘bigotry’ whenever she encounters it, following reports of significant numbers of people leaving the party because they do not consider it to be a safe and tolerant place for trans people. 

Ms Cherry has also been an outspoken critic of Ms Sturgeon and is viewed as a likely future SNP leadership candidate. 

She hit out in November last year as she said the SNP ‘shouldn’t be about the cult of leader, whether it’s Alex or Nicola, or anyone else’. 

She had been serving as the party’s justice and home affairs spokeswoman at Westminster. The reshuffle revealed that Anne McLaughlin has now been appointed as the party’s Westminster spokeswoman on justice and immigration.

Ms Cherry tweeted: ‘Despite hard work, results & a strong reputation I’ve been sacked today from @theSNP front bench.’

She added: ‘Westminster is increasingly irrelevant to Scotland’s constitutional future and @theSNP would do well to radically rethink our strategy.’

There was no mention of Ms Cherry in Mr Blackford’s reshuffle statement. 

He said: ‘We have a wealth of talent and experience and this reshuffle of SNP MPs ensures we are in the best possible position to hold the UK government to account during this global pandemic and the aftermath of Brexit, to support colleagues ahead of the Scottish elections, and to deliver independence.’ 

Ms Cherry’s profile increased significantly after she successfully challenged Boris Johnson’s plans for the prorogation of Parliament in 2019.