Moscow’s camera network that uses facial recognition does NOT violate citizens’ privacy, court rules


A Moscow court ruled on Tuesday that the city’s facial recognition system does not violate the privacy of its citizens – a blow to activists who had hoped to ban the technology’s use.

City authorities are using facial recognition technology to ensure people ordered to remain at home or at their hotels under coronavirus quarantine do so.

Lawyer and activist Alena Popova and opposition politician Vladimir Milov of the Solidarnost party had filed a case against Moscow´s Department of Technology (DIT), which manages the capital´s video surveillance program, seeking to ban the technology´s use at mass events and protests.

Moscow completed its facial recognition rollout with the awarding of a small software contract in December, having already spent at least 3.3 billion roubles ($50 million) on hardware, and its system now boasts more than 105,000 surveillance cameras fitted with the technology.

Scroll down for video 

A Moscow court ruled on Tuesday that the city’s facial recognition system does not violate the privacy of its citizens -a blow to activists who had hoped to ban the technology’s use

‘This ruling shows there are no legal defenses for facial recognition complaints,’ said Popova’s lawyer, Kirill Koroteev.

Popova also had a November lawsuit dismissed on the same grounds.

The DIT did not immediately respond to a Reuters request for comment.

On its website, the DIT says it uses video surveillance in crowded areas to ‘ensure safety,’ and that video footage is deleted within five days of an incident, unless a request by the public or law enforcement is made.

Russia has temporarily barred Chinese nationals from entering its boarders to curb the spread of the virus, but has welcomed Russians who return with an order to spend two weeks at home, even in the absence of symptoms.

City authorities are using facial recognition technology to ensure people ordered to remain at home or at their hotels under coronavirus quarantine do so

City authorities are using facial recognition technology to ensure people ordered to remain at home or at their hotels under coronavirus quarantine do so

Sergei Sobyanin, the mayor of Moscow, said some 2,500 people who had landed in the city from China had been ordered to go into quarantine.

To prevent them leaving their apartments, the authorities are using facial recognition technology in the city to catch any offenders, he said.

Compliance with the regime is constantly monitored, including with the help of facial recognition systems and other technical measures,’ he wrote on his website.

In one case described by Sobyanin, surveillance footage showed a woman who had returned from China leaving her apartment and meeting friends outside.

The authorities were able to track down the taxi driver who had taken her home from the airport thanks to video footage, Sobyanin said.

Sobyanin said the city was also forced to carry out raids against possible carriers of the virus, something he said was ‘unpleasant but necessary.’

Russia has temporarily barred Chinese nationals from entering its boarders to curb the spread of the virus, but has welcomed Russians who return with an order to spend two weeks at home, even in the absence of symptoms

Russia has temporarily barred Chinese nationals from entering its boarders to curb the spread of the virus, but has welcomed Russians who return with an order to spend two weeks at home, even in the absence of symptoms

Sergei Sobyanin, the mayor of Moscow, said some 2,500 people who had landed in the city from China had been ordered to go into quarantine. To prevent them leaving their apartments, the authorities are using facial recognition technology in the city to catch any offenders, he said (pictured is the current statistics of coronavirus around the world)

Sergei Sobyanin, the mayor of Moscow, said some 2,500 people who had landed in the city from China had been ordered to go into quarantine. To prevent them leaving their apartments, the authorities are using facial recognition technology in the city to catch any offenders, he said (pictured is the current statistics of coronavirus around the world)

The Moscow mayor’s office did not immediately reply to a request for comment.

Sobyanin said last month that the city had begun using facial recognition as part of its city security surveillance program.

Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said he had not seen details of the actions being taken in Moscow but that measures to curb the spread of the coronavirus should not be discriminatory.

The clamp down on quarantine rules comes after a woman in St. Petersburg staged an elaborate escape from a hospital where she said she was being kept against her will.

The incident, which resulted in a court ordering her to return to the quarantine facility, raised questions about the robustness of Russia’s coronavirus quarantine measures.

Russia has reported two cases of the illness – two Chinese nationals who have since recovered and been released from hospital, according to the authorities.